EEAT Mechanics

Crime demotion: results moved down on crime-related searches

A twiddler with settings, query signals and result signals can push pages down when a search concerns crime. Google publicly describes a related demotion of sites with exploitative practices around removing personal information, but never mentions crime queries. What exactly this twiddler targets is not known.

By Thomas Wawra· Published · Version 1.0· Systems referenced: Mustang / SuperRoot etc.

01What the schema shows

Three schema objects in the twiddler namespace belong to crime demotion. CrimeDemotionParams holds the settings sent with the query. CrimeDemotionQuerySignals holds signals about the query, CrimeDemotionResultSignals signals about each result.

RESONEO reads this as a demotion that applies after ranking when a search concerns crime: one measure for how crime-related the query is, one for each result. Which pages it targets, for example sites that publish arrest photos or court records, is not stated. Like every twiddler, it only recommends; the framework in Superroot, the layer that fans a query out to Google's indexes and merges what comes back, decides.

Source per claim (2)
C
Crime demotion has three schema objects: CrimeDemotionParams (settings), CrimeDemotionQuerySignals (per query) and CrimeDemotionResultSignals (per result).[1]
C
According to RESONEO, pages can be moved down after ranking on crime-related searches, with one measurement taken on the search and another on every result.[2]

02What Google says publicly

Google's ranking systems guide describes demotions based on removals. For personal information, it says that if Google processes many removals involving a site with exploitative removal practices, it demotes other content from that site. It also looks for the same pattern on other sites. RESONEO reads exploitative practices as asking for payment before taking personal data down; the guide itself does not spell this out here.

The guide does not mention crime, arrests or mugshots. Its demotion is triggered by removal requests and acts on a site, while the twiddler has signals per query and per result. The two may be related, as RESONEO suggests, but the public text does not connect them.

Source per claim (3)
O
"If we process a significant volume of personal information removals involving a site with exploitative removal practices…" Google demotes other content from that site.[3]
O
Google also checks whether the same pattern of behaviour occurs on other sites and, if so, applies demotions to content on those sites.[3]
C
The ranking systems guide does not mention crime, arrests or mugshots; its removal-based demotion acts per site, the twiddler per query and per result. The link between them is an inference.[4]

03E-E-A-T and the system map

Crime demotion has no E-E-A-T bearing that can be shown. It looks like a harm rule, protecting people named in crime-related results, not a judgement of expertise or authority. On our map it belongs to the twiddler layer.

Whether news sites that report on crime are affected, or only certain kinds of sites, is not known. Nothing public suggests that ordinary crime reporting is a target.

Source per claim (1)
C
Crime demotion is best read as a harm rule with no demonstrable E-E-A-T bearing; which kinds of sites it affects is unknown.[4]

04References

This Deep Dive is Layer 2 content. It interprets the material and always points back to Layer 1, the reference layer. Every claim is mapped to a source, labeled by type: [A] Sworn testimony · [B] Verbatim from the leak · [O] Documented by Google · [W] Peer-reviewed study · [S] Checked on the page · [C] Our assessment · [P] Patent.

© Thomas Wawra · Senior SEO Manager · wetter.com — a Funke Digital company